LeftlineTopline
Analysis and Comment

Bad Arguments

27 walnuts are worth 1 lemon

An argument is bad usually because a premiss is untenable or the logic employed in the argument is unsound. Premisses are sometimes right-sounding but irrelevant, sometimes simply wrong or unjust. The steps used to progress from premisses to conclusion are sometimes not logical, as a result of which the conclusion does not follow. Conclusions, in such cases, are usually pre-determined and the argument is a rationalization.

DateTitle
July 2004Constructive about Iraq
Disagreeing about current plans for Iraq is portrayed as being destructive. This is not only incorrect but also an attempt to give the occupation legitimacy.
June 2004On Self-Interest
Using self-interest as a tool of behavioural analysis is sensible. Using it as a principle to guide behaviour is pessimistic.