Leftline Topline
Analysis and Comment

Thinking Straight

Pear with surprise

Today, it is common to hear nonsensical arguments made with the utmost seriousness—and for these to be received with equal seriousness by nominally sane, rational, and civilized people. This in liberal democratic societies, where one might expect to find respect for truth, logic, decency. How does the dull-headedness come about?

Synopses of sections
Popular Beliefs
Every human action presupposes beliefs and attitudes, most of which are not consciously formulated, some of which are emotionally held. Public rhetoric and ideas prevalent in a society play a large part in shaping beliefs.
How's the Evidence?
Tall claims (Iraqi WMD, for example) or claims based on inaccurate or insufficient evidence (perceived threats of terrorism) are often used to press for certain courses of action. Examining the evidence critically and balancing it against opposing evidence usually helps clear the picture.
Bad Arguments
Because I don't see an elephant in the fridge doesn't mean there isn't one there might sound logical to a person in a hurry. But wouldn't you bet that the nearest an elephant could be is in the city zoo? Speciousness is all around us. It's shown up only if one thinks through it. And that means effort.
The Right Thing
An ends-justify-the-means argument. It usually indicates there isn't a presentable reason for the proposed action. Good people are called upon to not think but, instead, to rally around for the common cause—whatever that may be.
The Quotable Windbag
Some people are so keen on spinning a story, or so immersed in double-think, they don't notice the strain they put on logic and credibility—or the audience cracking up.
You Said It!
A collection of clear-headed comments and sensible ideas about topical issues. A counterpoint to the logic-defying loquacity of the windbags.